Shingle Roofing
Compare asphalt shingle options for your Columbus home with the full roof in mind.
Two shingles can look similar in a sample book and come with different performance ratings, installation requirements and warranty coverage. The product name matters as much as the color.
Supreme Roofing & Exterior provides shingle roofing services in Columbus and surrounding communities. We help homeowners consider asphalt roofing options for their home’s appearance and budget. If you are replacing an older roof, the condition of the existing system also belongs in that decision.
Compare the main asphalt shingle styles
Asphalt shingles come in a range of profiles and colors. These common categories describe their construction and appearance; the exact product determines its listed performance and coverage.
Three tab shingles
Three-tab shingles use a single-layer design with a regular tab pattern. They are generally positioned as an economical option. Ask about current product availability and compare the complete installed cost with other choices.
Architectural shingles
Architectural shingles, also called dimensional or laminated shingles, use bonded layers to create more depth. Compare the named products within this category, since appearance alone does not establish wind or impact performance.
Designer shingles
Designer or premium shingles offer more pronounced profiles and distinctive patterns, including looks inspired by shake or slate. The additional cost should be considered alongside the look you want and the product specifications.
GAF’s shingle selection guide provides examples of these categories. Bring preferred styles or colors to the consultation so we can discuss suitable available options.

Read wind ratings and warranty limits carefully
A wind-test classification and a manufacturer’s wind-warranty limit describe different things. Check the exact product documents, including any installation conditions attached to the advertised coverage. A number in a brochure does not predict the wind speed at which your particular roof will fail.
Discuss the roof’s condition and exposure alongside product selection. If shingles have lifted or gone missing after a storm, a roof inspection can help determine what needs attention. A repair may be appropriate when damage is limited; the shingle’s category alone does not decide that.

Consider impact resistance as a separate choice
A UL 2218 Class 4 designation describes performance in a laboratory impact test using steel balls. It does not mean a roof is hailproof. Impact resistance should be checked for the specific shingle being proposed.
The Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety publishes impact-resistant shingle performance ratings based on its own testing. These offer another way to compare tested products. Confirm the current product name and availability when considering an upgrade.
If potential insurance savings affect your budget, ask your insurer whether the proposed product qualifies and what documentation it requires. Get that answer before treating a discount as part of the project savings.

Separate expected roof life from warranty coverage
There is no single lifespan that applies to every asphalt shingle roof. The materials, installation, roof conditions and care all matter. A warranty term is not a prediction of how long the roof will remain serviceable.
A limited lifetime product warranty can have conditions and coverage that changes over time. It may also differ from workmanship coverage. For example, Owens Corning’s warranty comparison separates product defects, wind, algae and workmanship coverage, with different eligibility requirements.
Ask for the warranty documents associated with the proposed system, including any registration or transfer requirements. Confirm which coverage is included in the quote and who provides it.
Compare complete roofing proposals
The price of the shingles is only one part of the project. When comparing proposals, check that the scope identifies:
- The manufacturer, product line, color and area of roof included.
- Removal of old roofing, any deck repairs and how concealed damage would be handled.
- Underlayment, starter and ridge products, flashing and ventilation work.
- Cleanup, disposal, applicable permit responsibilities and the warranty being offered.
Ask for the selected product’s wind, impact and fire classifications where relevant. Product weight and suitability should be considered for the roof itself, rather than assuming every roofing material can be substituted without review.
Our roof installation page explains the parts of a roofing system. For an aging roof, our roof replacement service covers the broader replacement project. Confirm the full scope before comparing a shingle upgrade by price alone.
Service area
Shingle roofing across the Columbus area
We serve Columbus and nearby communities including Upper Arlington, Grove City, Dublin, Westerville, Hilliard, Gahanna, New Albany and Reynoldsburg. Our service area page lists additional locations. Share your address and the work you are considering to discuss availability.
- Columbus
- Upper Arlington
- Grove City
- Dublin
- Westerville
- Hilliard
- Gahanna
- New Albany
- Reynoldsburg
FAQ
Questions about choosing asphalt shingles
Can a repair match my existing shingles
A close match may be possible, depending on the existing product, its age, weathering and current availability. Share any product records you have. Discuss the likely appearance of a repaired section before selecting replacement shingles.
How should I choose a shingle color
Compare samples with the siding, brick and trim you plan to keep. Look at the color outdoors and consider the roof as a large surface. If your property has architectural approval requirements, confirm them before ordering.
Can asphalt shingles cover a nearly flat porch roof
Suitability depends on the actual slope and the product’s installation requirements. A low-slope section may need a different system. Our flat rubber roofing service covers another option for appropriate roof areas.
Are asphalt shingles maintenance free
No. Follow the care guidance for the selected system and address leaks, missing shingles or new damage when they appear. Discuss ongoing checks through our roof maintenance service.
More services
Related roofing services
See all roofing services, or explore gutters and siding.
Discuss shingle options for your roof
Tell us what you want to change, what you want to keep and whether the current roof has any known problems. Contact Supreme Roofing & Exterior for a free consultation, or email info@supremeexterior.com.